Bored Piers vs Driven Piles: Understanding the Difference

Bored piers are deep foundations created by drilling a hole into the ground, inserting a steel reinforcement cage, and filling it with concrete. Driven piles are prefabricated columns (concrete, steel, or timber) forced into the ground using a pile driver. In Australia, the choice between the two depends on soil conditions, project size, load requirements, noise restrictions, and budget. Bored piers suit complex or obstructed ground and sensitive urban sites, while driven piles are faster and more cost-effective in suitable granular soils.

Every building project starts with its foundation. Whether you are constructing a residential home, a multi-storey apartment building, or a commercial development, the foundation must be strong enough to support the structure and stable enough to resist soil movement over time. In Australia, where soil types range from reactive clays in Melbourne's western suburbs to sandy ground along the Queensland coast, selecting the right foundation method is a decision that affects the safety, longevity, and cost of the entire project.

What Are Bored Piers?

Bored piers (also called drilled shafts or caissons) are deep foundations constructed by drilling a cylindrical hole into the ground to a specified depth and diameter. Once the hole is drilled, a steel reinforcement cage is lowered into it, and concrete is poured to fill the shaft. The result is a solid concrete column that transfers the building's weight down through weak or unstable soil layers to a stronger bearing stratum below.

How Bored Piers Are Constructed

Advantages of Bored Piers

• Flexible in size and depth, suitable for a wide range of project requirements
• Effective in complex soil conditions, including reactive clays, rock, and ground with underground obstructions
• Produces significantly less noise and vibration than driven piles, making them suitable for urban and sensitive sites
• Can achieve very high load-bearing capacities by drilling into bedrock or competent strata
• Can be constructed in areas with limited overhead clearance

Limitations of Bored Piers

• Generally more time-consuming to construct than driven piles
• Can be more expensive due to specialised drilling equipment and the need for casing in unstable ground
• Quality depends heavily on the drilling and concreting process, as defects (such as voids or poor concrete coverage) can occur underground and are difficult to detect
• Spoil (excavated soil) must be removed from the site and disposed of

What Are Driven Piles?

Driven piles are prefabricated columns, typically made of reinforced concrete, steel (H-piles or tube piles), or treated timber, that are driven into the ground using a pile-driving hammer. The hammer delivers repeated blows to the top of the pile, forcing it into the soil until it reaches the required depth or resistance.

How Driven Piles Are Constructed

Advantages of Driven Piles

• Faster installation than bored piers in suitable soil conditions
• Prefabrication ensures consistent quality control
• High load-bearing capacity, particularly in granular soils
• No spoil (excavated material) to remove from site
• Can be driven through soft layers to reach firm bearing strata

Limitations of Driven Piles

• Generates significant noise and vibration during installation, which can be disruptive in urban areas and may trigger dilapidation concerns for neighbouring properties
• Difficult or impossible to install in hard rock or ground with large underground obstructions
• Less flexible in terms of depth adjustments once fabricated
• May cause ground heave or displacement in cohesive soils

Bored Piers vs Driven Piles Comparison

When to Choose Bored Piers

• The site has complex or variable soil conditions, including reactive clays, fill material, or underground obstructions
• The project is in a noise-sensitive urban area where pile-driving vibration could damage neighbouring structures or breach council noise regulations
• The structure requires very high load-bearing capacity that can only be achieved by drilling into bedrock
• The site has limited access that prevents large pile-driving rigs from operating

When to Choose Driven Piles

• The soil is granular (sand, gravel) and suitable for pile driving without risk of refusal from rock
• Speed is a priority and the site allows for the noise and vibration of pile driving
• The project budget favours the lower cost of prefabricated piles in suitable conditions
• Quality control through factory prefabrication is preferred over in-situ concrete work

Soil Conditions and Foundation Choice

Australian soil types vary widely by region, and understanding your site's soil is the starting point for choosing the right foundation.

• Reactive clays (common in Melbourne's west, parts of Adelaide, and western Sydney): these soils expand and shrink with moisture changes, making bored piers or piers to stable strata the preferred choice
• Sandy soils (common along the QLD coast and parts of Perth): driven piles often work well in these conditions due to the ease of driving through granular material
• Rock (common in parts of Sydney and the Blue Mountains): bored piers can be drilled into rock for high load capacity, while driven piles may meet early refusal
• Fill and mixed ground: sites with fill or variable ground conditions often require bored piers to reach stable bearing layers below the fill

The Importance of Geotechnical Surveys

A geotechnical survey (soil investigation) is the first step in determining which foundation method is appropriate. The survey involves drilling test bores, collecting soil samples, and laboratory testing to establish:

• Soil type and bearing capacity at various depths
• Groundwater level (water table depth)
• Presence of rock, fill, or underground obstructions
• Soil reactivity classification under Australian Standard AS 2870

Foundation Inspections

Regardless of whether bored piers or driven piles are used, independent foundation inspections are important to verify that the work meets the engineering specifications and complies with the NCC.

• Pre-pour inspections for bored piers: verify hole depth, diameter, reinforcement cage placement, and cleanliness of the base before concrete is poured
• Pile driving records: check that each pile has reached the required depth or refusal, and review driving records for consistency
• Post-installation testing: load testing confirms that the foundation can support the designed loads
• Construction stage inspections at the foundation stage catch defects before they are buried under concrete and subsequent work

Related Articles

Australia's Top 10 Most Common Building Defects

Building defects remain one of the biggest concerns for Australian property owners and buyers. From water leaks and waterproofing failures to building movement and subsidence, these are the ten most common defects found during professional building inspections across the country.

Structural Defect Inspections to Prevent Future Problems

Approximately one in five Australian homes experience structural issues. Learn how structural defect inspections can prevent expensive repairs and ensure safety.

Construction Progress Inspections

Construction progress inspections are one of the most effective ways to keep your building project on time and on budget. This guide explains what happens at each inspection stage, who should be involved, and how regular checks protect homeowners and developers from costly rework and disputes.