Filing an insurance claim for property or construction damage can be a stressful experience. Whether you are a homeowner dealing with storm damage, a builder managing a construction defect claim, or a contractor facing liability issues, understanding how insurers assess claims gives you a significant advantage.
In Australia, insurance companies follow a structured process when evaluating claims. This process involves multiple stages, several parties, and detailed documentation requirements. Knowing what to expect at each stage helps you prepare a stronger claim and avoid the common mistakes that lead to delays, underpayment, or outright denial.
The Six Stages of Insurance Claim Assessment
Australian insurers follow a broadly consistent process when handling property and construction claims. While the specifics may vary between companies, the general framework includes six stages that move from initial lodgement through to final settlement.
Understanding these stages allows you to anticipate what the insurer needs at each point and provide the right information at the right time.
Claim Lodgement
You notify the insurer of the loss or damage and provide initial details.
Appointment of Specialist Assessor
The insurer appoints a loss adjuster or specialist to investigate.
Investigation and Evidence Gathering
The assessor inspects the site, collects evidence, and interviews relevant parties.
Coverage Determination
The insurer reviews the policy to confirm what is and is not covered.
Valuation of Loss or Damage
Repair costs, replacement values, and associated losses are calculated.
Decision and Settlement
The insurer approves, partially approves, or denies the claim and issues payment.
Stage 1: Claim Lodgement
The process begins when you notify your insurer of the loss or damage. Most Australian insurers provide 24-hour claims hotlines, online portals, and mobile apps for lodging claims. At this stage, the insurer collects basic information about the incident, including the date and time of the event, the type of damage, and a brief description of what occurred.
Prompt lodgement matters. Many policies require notification within a reasonable timeframe, and delays can weaken your position. When you lodge the claim, you will receive a claim reference number that you should keep for all future correspondence.
What to Have Ready When Lodging
Your policy number, a brief description of the damage, the date and time of the incident, any emergency repair receipts, and initial photographs of the damage. Having these details ready speeds up the process considerably.
Stage 2: Appointment of Specialist Assessor
For anything beyond minor claims, the insurer will appoint a specialist assessor, typically a loss adjuster or building consultant. Loss adjusters are independent professionals who investigate claims on behalf of the insurer. Their job is to determine what happened, assess the extent of damage, and recommend a settlement amount.
For construction-related claims, the insurer may also appoint structural engineers, quantity surveyors, or forensic building experts depending on the nature and complexity of the damage.
The assessor will contact you to arrange a site visit. This visit usually occurs within one to two weeks of lodgement, though natural disaster events can push this out significantly due to high claim volumes.
Stage 3: Investigation and Evidence Gathering
This is the most detailed stage of the process. The appointed assessor conducts a thorough on-site inspection, documenting damage through photographs, measurements, and written observations. They will examine structural elements, services, fixtures, and any contents affected by the incident.
The investigation typically includes:
- A visual assessment of all affected areas
- Photographic and video documentation
- Review of maintenance records and building history
- Interviews with property owners, tenants, builders, or witnesses
- Assessment of the cause and origin of the damage
- Identification of any pre-existing conditions
The assessor may also request access to building plans, previous inspection reports, council approvals, and any contracts with builders or tradespeople. If you have an independent building inspection report, this is the stage where it becomes particularly valuable as supporting evidence.
Stage 4: Coverage Determination
Once the investigation is complete, the insurer reviews your policy to determine exactly what is covered. This stage involves detailed analysis of the policy wording, including coverage limits, exclusions, conditions, and any endorsements or special provisions.
Common exclusions in Australian construction and property policies include:
- Wear and tear or gradual deterioration
- Damage caused by poor maintenance or neglect
- Settling, shrinkage, or ground movement (unless specifically covered)
- Faulty workmanship (though consequential damage may be covered)
- Flood damage (unless flood cover is included)
Warning
Policy exclusions are one of the most common reasons claims are reduced or denied. Review your policy carefully before an incident occurs so you understand any gaps in your coverage.
Stage 5: Valuation of Loss or Damage
After confirming coverage, the insurer calculates the financial value of the claim. This valuation considers repair costs, replacement costs, temporary accommodation or business interruption expenses, and any other consequential losses covered by the policy.
The insurer may obtain independent repair quotes, use their own panel of builders, or rely on the loss adjuster's cost estimate. Discrepancies between the insurer's valuation and your own builder's quote are common and can be a source of dispute.
| Valuation Method | How It Works | When It Is Used |
|---|---|---|
| Repair cost estimate | Assessor calculates the cost to restore the property to pre-damage condition | Most property damage claims |
| Replacement value | Cost to replace damaged items with new equivalents | Contents claims and total loss scenarios |
| Indemnity value | Current market value accounting for age and depreciation | Older properties or items with significant wear |
| Agreed value | Pre-determined amount agreed when the policy was taken out | Specialty or high-value items |
Stage 6: Decision and Settlement
The insurer makes a final decision based on all gathered information. Claims can be approved in full, approved in part, or denied. If approved, settlement may take the form of a cash payment, managed repairs using the insurer's preferred contractors, or a combination of both.
Under the General Insurance Code of Practice, insurers must inform you of their decision within specific timeframes. If your claim is denied or only partially approved, the insurer must provide written reasons and advise you of your dispute resolution options.
Chain of Responsibility in Construction Claims
Construction insurance claims often involve multiple parties, and determining who is responsible for what can be complicated. The chain of responsibility in a construction project typically includes the property owner, head contractor, subcontractors, architects, engineers, and product manufacturers.
When damage occurs during or after construction, the insurer must determine which party's actions or products caused the problem. This analysis considers:
- Contractual obligations between parties
- Compliance with the Building Code of Australia (BCA)
- Adherence to Australian Standards
- State and territory building legislation
- Product warranties and manufacturer responsibilities
| Party | Typical Responsibilities | Common Insurance Type |
|---|---|---|
| Property Owner | Maintaining property, disclosing defects | Home and contents, building insurance |
| Head Contractor | Overall build quality, site safety, subcontractor oversight | Contract works, public liability |
| Subcontractors | Quality of specific trade work | Public liability, professional indemnity |
| Architects and Engineers | Design adequacy, specification compliance | Professional indemnity |
| Product Manufacturers | Product performance and safety | Product liability |
Building Defects Insurance
In several Australian states, builders are required to hold building defects insurance (also known as home warranty insurance or domestic building insurance). This insurance protects property owners if the builder dies, disappears, or becomes insolvent and is unable to fix defects or complete work.
Coverage periods vary by state. In New South Wales, for example, the Home Building Compensation Fund covers structural defects for six years and non-structural defects for two years from completion. Victoria has similar provisions under the Domestic Building Insurance scheme.
It is worth noting that building defects insurance is a last resort. It only applies when the builder cannot be pursued directly. If the builder is still operating, the first step is to seek rectification from them under the building contract and relevant consumer protection laws.
State Variations Apply
Building defects insurance requirements and coverage periods differ between states and territories. Check the rules that apply in your jurisdiction before relying on this type of cover.
Alternative Dispute Resolution
If you disagree with the outcome of your insurance claim assessment, you do not have to accept the insurer's decision. Australia has a well-established framework for resolving insurance disputes without going to court.
Internal Dispute Resolution (IDR): Every insurer must have a formal complaints process. You can request a review of the claim decision, and the insurer must respond within 30 calendar days.
Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA): If the internal process does not resolve the dispute, you can escalate to AFCA. This is a free, independent service that can make binding decisions on insurers for claims up to $1 million. AFCA considers whether the insurer acted fairly and in accordance with the policy terms.
State tribunals and courts: For disputes outside AFCA's jurisdiction or where you prefer a different process, state consumer tribunals (such as NCAT in NSW or VCAT in Victoria) offer accessible dispute resolution pathways.
Mediation and expert determination: Some policies include provisions for mediation or expert determination, where an independent third party helps resolve disagreements about claim valuation or coverage.
Having strong documentation and an independent building inspection report can be a deciding factor in disputes. Professional, impartial evidence carries significant weight in all of these forums.
How to Prepare for an Insurance Claim Assessment
Good preparation can make the difference between a smooth claim experience and a drawn-out dispute. The following recommendations apply whether you are making a claim for storm damage, construction defects, or any other insured event.
Document everything immediately. As soon as it is safe to do so, photograph and video all damage from multiple angles. Include wide shots for context and close-ups for detail. Record dates and times.
Prevent further damage. Take reasonable steps to stop the damage from getting worse. Tarp a leaking roof, board up broken windows, or turn off water at the mains if pipes have burst. Keep all receipts for materials and emergency repairs.
Gather your records. Pull together your insurance policy, building contracts, previous inspection reports, maintenance records, and receipts for any items you plan to claim. The more organised your documentation, the faster the assessment proceeds.
Get an independent assessment. Engaging a licensed building inspector to document the damage independently gives you a professional report that supports your claim. This is particularly valuable if you anticipate any disagreement with the insurer's assessment.
Keep a claims diary. Record every phone call, email, and interaction with your insurer, including the date, the person you spoke with, and what was discussed. This record protects you if disputes arise later about what was communicated.
Review your policy before the assessor visits. Understanding your coverage limits, excess amounts, and any exclusions helps you set realistic expectations and ask informed questions during the assessment.
Frequently Asked Questions
QWhat should I do immediately after discovering property damage?
Ensure personal safety first, then document all damage with photographs and video before any cleanup. Contact your insurer as soon as possible to lodge the claim and take reasonable steps to prevent further damage.
Keep receipts for any emergency repairs or temporary measures. Do not dispose of damaged materials until the assessor has inspected them, as they may need to verify the cause and extent of the damage.
QHow can I prepare before an incident occurs?
Maintain an up-to-date home inventory with photographs, receipts, and valuations of significant items. Review your insurance policy annually to confirm coverage levels match your property's current value.
Keep digital copies of all important documents in a secure cloud-based location. Arrange regular building inspections to document your property's condition, which provides a baseline if you ever need to make a claim.
QWhat are the most common mistakes people make during insurance claims?
The most common mistakes include delayed reporting, insufficient documentation, disposing of damaged materials before inspection, making permanent repairs before the assessor visits, and failing to read and understand the policy terms.
Other frequent errors include not keeping a record of communications with the insurer, underestimating the full scope of damage, and not seeking independent professional advice when the claim is complex or high in value.
QWhat documentation do I need to support my insurance claim?
You need photographs and video of all damage, your insurance policy details, proof of ownership or value for contents claims, repair quotes from licensed tradespeople, and any previous inspection or maintenance records.
For construction claims, also gather building contracts, approved plans, certificates of compliance, and correspondence with your builder. An independent building inspection report provides professional evidence of the damage and its likely cause.
QHow long does the insurance claim assessment process typically take?
Straightforward claims are usually resolved within 30 to 45 days. Complex claims involving significant damage, disputes about coverage, or specialist assessments can take three to six months or longer.
Natural disaster events often cause backlogs that extend processing times for all affected policyholders. You can help speed up the process by providing complete documentation upfront and responding promptly to any requests for additional information.
QShould I hire a third-party consultant for my insurance claim?
For complex or high-value claims, engaging an independent building inspector or public adjuster can significantly improve your outcome. These professionals provide impartial evidence and can identify damage the insurer's assessor may have missed.
A licensed building inspector typically charges between $300 and $800 depending on the property and scope of work. Public adjusters usually charge a percentage of the settlement amount, typically 5 to 15 percent. For large claims, the investment is often well worth it.
QWhat options do I have if my insurer denies or underpays my claim?
You can request written reasons for the decision, lodge an internal complaint with the insurer, escalate to the Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA) for free independent review, or pursue the matter through a state tribunal or court.
Gather additional supporting evidence such as independent inspection reports before escalating. AFCA can make binding decisions on insurers for claims up to $1 million and is free for consumers to use.
QWhat is underinsurance and how does it affect my claim?
Underinsurance occurs when your sum insured is less than the actual cost to rebuild or replace your property. If you are underinsured, the insurer may apply an averaging clause and only pay a proportion of your loss.
For example, if your property would cost $800,000 to rebuild but you are only insured for $600,000, the insurer may reduce your payout proportionally. Review your sum insured annually and account for rising construction costs to avoid this situation.
QCan I claim on multiple insurance policies for the same damage?
You can lodge claims with multiple insurers if more than one policy covers the damage, but you cannot receive more than the total value of your loss. Insurers will coordinate between themselves through a contribution process.
This situation commonly arises in construction where both the builder's contract works policy and the owner's building insurance may respond to the same event. You must disclose all relevant policies to each insurer.
QHow should I communicate with my insurer during the claims process?
Confirm all verbal conversations in writing by following up phone calls with an email summarising what was discussed. Keep copies of all correspondence and maintain a detailed claims diary recording dates, names, and key points.
Be factual and concise in your communications. Respond to requests for information promptly and ask for timeframes whenever the insurer commits to an action. If you feel the process is being unreasonably delayed, you have the right to lodge a formal complaint.
Key Takeaways
- Australian insurers assess claims through six stages: lodgement, assessor appointment, investigation, coverage determination, valuation, and settlement.
- Prompt lodgement and thorough documentation are the two most influential factors in achieving a fair claim outcome.
- Loss adjusters are appointed by the insurer, but you have the right to engage your own independent experts.
- Construction claims often involve a chain of responsibility across multiple parties including owners, contractors, and designers.
- Building defects insurance is a last resort that only applies when the builder cannot be pursued directly.
- Policy exclusions for wear and tear, poor maintenance, and faulty workmanship are common reasons claims are reduced or denied.
- If you disagree with the insurer's decision, free dispute resolution is available through AFCA.
- An independent building inspection report provides professional evidence that supports your claim and strengthens your position in any dispute.
References and Resources
Related Articles
What is an Insurance Claim Assessment?
Insurance claim assessments evaluate property damage, review policy coverage, and determine appropriate compensation. Learn the process and documentation requirements.
How Does Weather Affect Property Inspection Reports in Australia?
Weather conditions can significantly influence the findings of a property inspection. Learn how rain, heat, and storms affect inspection outcomes.
How to Build a Resilient Home for Extreme Weather in Australia
Extreme weather events are increasing in frequency across Australia. Discover construction strategies that protect your home against storms, floods, and bushfire.
Need Help With Your Insurance Claim?
Our licensed building inspectors provide independent property damage assessments and reports that support insurance claims across Australia.