Common Issues in Structural Insurance Claims

Structural insurance claims can be challenging to navigate, often leading to disputes, delays, and financial stress for homeowners, builders, and property professionals. Understanding these common pitfalls and handling them effectively is crucial for ensuring successful claims and safeguarding investments.

What is Structural Insurance?

Structural insurance provides financial protection to property owners, developers, and builders against significant structural defects that could compromise the integrity and safety of a building. It is designed to cover unforeseen structural failures caused by design flaws, substandard materials, or construction defects. This insurance is particularly valuable for new builds and major renovations, as problems often emerge long after construction.

Who Needs Structural Insurance?

• Homeowners: Protects against hidden defects that may not have been evident at purchase.
• Builders & Developers: Essential for meeting regulatory requirements and ensuring buyer confidence.
• Property Investors: Helps mitigate financial risks associated with structural damage and defects, preserving asset value.

What Does Structural Insurance Cover?

Structural insurance generally covers:

• Foundation failures, including subsidence, heaving, and settlement issues that compromise structural integrity.
• Roof collapses caused by inadequate construction, improper materials, or unforeseen stress factors.
• Structural movement may occur due to design flaws or poor workmanship.
• Major construction defects include poorly installed load-bearing walls, weak framing, or substandard concrete mixes.

Related article: Guide to Insurance Claim Assessments for Property Damage

What Is Not Covered?

While structural insurance offers broad protection, exclusions commonly include:

• Normal wear and tear over time.
• Poor maintenance leads to preventable damage.
• Unauthorized modifications were not approved by the insurer or built without proper compliance.

Common Issues in Structural Insurance Claims

1. Delayed Detection of Structural Defects

Structural damage may take years to become apparent, particularly in foundation movement or gradual material degradation. Many insurance policies have strict reporting timeframes, and failure to report damage promptly can lead to claim denial.

Example: A homeowner notices cracks in the walls five years after moving in. When they file a claim, the insurer rejects it due to a clause requiring damage to be reported within three years of construction completion.

Solution: Conduct regular inspections and document minor issues before they escalate into significant defects. Retain engineer reports as evidence if claims arise.

2. Policy Exclusions and Limitations

Insurers often include specific exclusions for damage attributed to maintenance neglect or pre-existing conditions. This can create disputes over coverage and responsibility.

Example: A roof collapses due to long-term water exposure from an undetected leak. The insurer denies the claim, arguing that maintenance failure contributed to the damage.

Solution: Homeowners should schedule annual maintenance checks and retain inspection records to demonstrate due diligence in property upkeep.

3. Insufficient Documentation

A lack of detailed documentation is one of the biggest reasons for claim delays or denials. Without proper records, insurers may dispute whether the damage is covered under the policy.

Solution: Homeowners and builders should maintain thorough records, including:

• High-quality photos showing the progression of damage.
• Engineer and inspector reports to validate claims.
• Repair invoices and receipts to demonstrate efforts made to mitigate damage.

4. Disputes Over the Cause of Damage

Insurers may attribute damage to natural ground movement or other factors outside of policy coverage, leading to disputes over responsibility.

Example: A homeowner files a claim for a sinking foundation, but the insurer argues it is due to normal settling rather than construction defects.

Solution: Obtain an independent structural engineer’s assessment to challenge insurer findings and substantiate the claim with expert analysis.

How to Handle Structural Insurance Claims Effectively

1. Report Issues Promptly

Most policies require claims to be filed within a specific timeframe after discovering a defect. Delaying action increases the risk of claim denial due to late reporting.

Action Step: As soon as damage is noticed, notify your insurer in writing and keep a log of all communication.

2. Gather Strong Documentation

Comprehensive documentation is the key to proving claim legitimacy.

• Photographs and video evidence of the damage over time.
• Professional assessments from licensed engineers or surveyors.
• Detailed repair invoices and receipts are needed to show the financial impact.

3. Understand Your Policy Terms

Before filing a claim, review your policy carefully to understand coverage limits and exclusions. If necessary, seek professional advice to clarify ambiguities.

Tip: Consult an insurance lawyer or claims specialist if the policy wording is unclear.

4. Hire an Independent Engineer

An independent structural engineer can provide an unbiased assessment that strengthens your case if the insurer disputes your claim.

5. Negotiate with the Insurer

If your claim is denied or undervalued, consider:

• Requesting a formal claim review.
• Escalating the dispute to the Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA).
• Seeking legal counsel if negotiations stall.

Preventative Measures to Avoid Future Claims

1. Regular Property Inspections

Annual inspections by licensed professionals help detect minor issues before they escalate into costly structural failures.

2. Ensure Quality Workmanship in Construction

Work with reputable, licensed builders and contractors who comply with Australian construction standards to reduce the likelihood of defects.

3. Maintain Detailed Records

Retain all construction warranties, engineer reports, and maintenance logs to support future insurance claims.

Take Control of Your Structural Insurance Claims

Structural insurance is an essential safeguard against construction defects, but successful claims require proactive documentation, timely reporting, and an understanding of policy limitations. Homeowners and property professionals can ensure they receive the coverage they are entitled to by maintaining clear records and seeking expert assessments when needed.

Get help from Owner Inspections team. Get a free quote.